
This is a play by play synopsis and defense. So yes, spoilers and things you may disagree with. If you do not want, go away.
This is going to be quite difficult to write, for many reasons. First, and obviously, it’s hard to see past the death of Ianto Jones when discussing this series. It took me months to even be able to rewatch it from start to finish. Second, Children of Earth is not an easy thing to understand or to peg down. It has many layers, and resolution that lends little satisfaction.
However, I do feel like it’s worth discussing. There is just too much to dissect to write it off as simply the story of the death of Ianto Jones. Pushing Children of Earth into that corner category doesn’t give enough credit to science fiction and those who created it. Speaking of creators, I wasn’t in the writer’s heads when they were doing this, and I obviously don’t have access to the bibles for season four so it’s hard for me to judge Children of Earth in terms of the longer Torchwood narrative. This is a fan’s view. That’s all.
Also, I don’t have the video with me, so I’m going to do the best I can from synopsis and memory. If things start getting too long, I may split the posts up.
That’s it. Here we go.
Day One
It took me a few rewatchings to pick up some of the cute Jack and Ianto details that, looking back, are a little heartbreaking. It seems they are at the point in their relationship where definitions start to become necessary. Presenting themselves a neighbours of a heart attack victim who is carrying an alien species inside him, this exchange ensues:
Ianto: Heh, he thought we were a couple, he said ‘You two’, the way he said it ‘You two’.
Jack: Well we are, does it matter?
Later, Jack said he hates the word couple, and Ianto hesitantly agrees with him. Ianto’s characteristic insecurities are papered all through CoE and that’s part of what makes it so hard. We’ve all been there right? In love with a shining star and you just don’t know for how long you can hold on to him. More on this later.
We are also introduced to Dr. Rupesh Patanjali. We are reminded of Owen first when Gwen says hello to his crumpled up picture on her desk, and then this smart young doctor comes along, tracking down the Hub, while Ianto and Jack watch and giggle and wonder how determined he is to know about Torchwood. Gwen says bollocks to this and goes out to have a chat with him. This chat is almost hopeful as we begin to think that the team may get rebuilt. Rupesh is a likeable character and would be watchable as Owen 2.0.
But CoE is not about hope. Maybe you could say CoE is about the anti-hope.
So the children start talking in unison which is completely creepy. How they wrangled so many school kids to stay still and talk in unison, I’ll never know. This starts off the mystery that Torchwood must tackle.
Ianto and Jack are thrown off their game, realizing that they need a kid to study in order to determine the cause of the behavior. This sets us up for yet another patented CoE heartbreaker. Jack wanders off without telling Ianto anything, only making a crack about ‘now who’s the couple’ when Ianto asks where he’s going. Then Ianto wanders off as well. Their mission? Suck up to their families so they can experiment on the children they’re related to.
Stop here. Okay another reason why CoE is so heartbreaking is that it shows our heroes being less than heroic. I don’t think this is a bad thing. I mean, it’s hard for regular Torchwood viewers because the heroes of Torchwood are just so stunning and almost comic-bookish. Jack Harkness always shows up with his Webley to save the day. Always. This is what he does. He says ‘I’ve got you,’ and this means everything is going to be okay.
Even the character flaws and mistakes throughout season 1 and 2 only served to bring the team closer together. They were heroic flaws. Ianto brought the cyberwoman in because he loved her, nearly ending all of humanity. Owen opened the rift to get Tosh and Jack back, and nearly ending all of humanity. Jack loses Grey in the attack in the future but he was only a kid, trying his best. I could go on.
Season 2 in ‘Adrift’ we start to see the darker side because practicality rears it’s ugly head. Jack can’t fix the people who get lost in the rift and spit back out, so he covers it up, and hides them away, and tells Gwen not to ask questions. It’s not pretty, but what is the other solution? Gwen’s solution causes the mother to freak out and have a breakdown, saying she wished she had never know the truth. The truth ain’t pretty.
Do we want science fiction with neat endings that wrap up at the 43 minute mark, just in time for a group hug, or do we want to grapple with issues like what do you do when none of the options or solutions are acceptable at all? I think you have the answer this question before you finish CoE. Personally, I think there’s a happy medium somewhere and Torchwood is going to have to find in season 4.
But I digress.
Back to Torchwood. Jack and Ianto have wandered off to visit their families in a VERY thinly veiled attempt to get children to experiment on. And their families, not being moron’s, see right through this and this shines a BRIGHT light on the characters of Jack and Ianto. It’s Torchwood first, the rest of the world second. We don’t want to see our heroes as crass workaholics who care nothing about human connection. Truth is, we’ve spent two seasons totally wrapped up in Torchwood, and now the writers are showing us that ‘hey, there’s something else going beside Torchwood.’
Okay okay, Jack does tell his daughter that he’d visit everyday if she’d let him. There is some very sad tension here. Jack obviously takes care of her financially and wants to be involved with Steven, but he’s also an immortal agent from the 51st century on a mission to protect humanity from alien technology. How do you explain that to the damn kid? Moreover, I think that Alice has been warned by her mother that with Jack comes danger and with Jack comes the potential for being abandoned so he has time to save the world. Can you smell the foreshadowing? I can.
Either way, the meeting doesn’t end well.
Meanwhile, Ianto visits his sister who is immediately suspicious as he hasn’t visited in ages and all of a sudden wants to take the kids out for fast food. Also, I believe Ianto gives the kids money. Which is hilarious. Ianto’s sister chides him for being away for so long, and they enter into what is probably the highlight of episode 1, for Ianto fans.
Ianto: So you have dinner with Tina.
Rhiannon: Not in town. Susan said he was gorgeous. Like a film star. Like an escort.
Ianto: He’s my boss.
Rhiannon: She said it was intimate. I said well he’s had girlfriends, and she said, well no girl was getting her feet around that table. No chance! have you gone bender?
Ianto: [looks at Misha] Misha’s hearing this.
Rhiannon: She’s not bothered. Her friend Shan gots two mothers. [pauses] Go on? [longer pause] You never tell me anything these days. Dad died that was it. You were off-you couldn’t wait. Like I did something wrong. I didn’t. Did I?
Ianto: [shaking his head] It’s not that. It’s my job. It’s..difficult. It’s…[closes his eyes for a second and opens them again] He is very handsome.
Rhiannon: No?
Ianto: Now stop it.
Rhiannon: You’re kidding me? Really though? Really? Christ all mighty! [pause] He’s nice though, is he? Is he? Oh my…I’m mean since when?
Ianto: It’s weird. It’s just different. It’s not men. It’s…it’s just him. It’s only him. And I don’t even know what it is really, so…so I’m not broadcasting it.
It also may have created some mild controversy. Some have said that this was an attempt to reign in Ianto’s gayness for whatever reason. Now I tread delicately here, but tread nonetheless. Jack is bisexual. There is no doubt in this. Jack doesn’t even limit himself to humans. Aliens, buckets of goo, it’s all good. This is just Jack. We love him for it. He’s a big ball of love and he’s got plenty to share.
Ianto, well Ianto falls in love hard. I mean, look at what he did for Lisa. Beyond even the constrains of logical storytelling reality, he gets a job at Torchwood, builds a secret lab to keep her alive, and keeps her there for what like 6 months? I mean, forget the quibbles I have with that whole episode, he’s pretty dedicated. I’m pretty sure during the Ianto/Lisa era, he would have easily said if asked, “It’s not women, it’s just Lisa.”
What he’s saying here is not that he’s not attracted to men (or women), it’s just that he’s so blinded by love for Jack, there is nothing else. Love for Jack makes anything possible, even a change of ’sexual lifestyle’.
Enter something fairly new to Torchwood: the extended side story. We are introduced to three new characters who live in a world completely outside Torchwood: politics. Lois Habiba (just found out that this was role intended to be completed by Martha Jones, but Freema had other obligations) is a combo of Martha Jones and her sister, who we’ve seen in Doctor Who working as a PA for PM Harold Saxon. We follow her on her first day at her new job as a PA (I love PAs) to John Frobisher, a high-ranking career civil servant, and Bridget Spears, his life long assistant.
Starting her job on the WORST FIRST DAY EVER, there is mass panic due to the mouthy trance children, and the Home Office is flooded with calls which Habiba and Spears must field. Now, I tell you as a person experienced in politics, this is quite a tricky thing. About 75% of the calls you would get are from quacks, or from other government officials asking stupid questions. These can be handled by secretaries. But a very good secretary knows which calls need to be pushed through to the official. This is a valuable skill. Lois does not have this skill yet. As a result, when she gets a call from Captain Jack from Torchwood saying he can help, he doesn’t get through. This wrankles Jack, but he regains his composure, is polite to Lois and wishes her good luck. Always the gentleman.
In the chaos, Spears has given Lois her pass codes to help with the work load, and when she logs the call as Torchwood, she get’s hit with all this information about Torchwood, which oddly enough seems to be in wiki style. I WISH I HAD ACCESS TO THAT WIKI. so much. So Lois is in the loop.
MI5’s Mr. Dekker tells Mr. Frobisher that it is indeed the 456 that have returned, Frobisher passes this along to the Prime Minister who promptly determines that the historical events leading up to this day, involving the 456 must be immediately erased. He also washes his hands clean of the whole situation and tells Frobisher to handle everything, including the elimination of everyone (including Jack Harkness) who was involved in the previous 456 visit.
And we stop here.
It is a little difficult as Canada and the UK have very similar systems of government, but we use different terminology. Frobisher is an under-secretary, which to us would probably mean he’s somewhere akin to a deputy minister, ie. a high-ranking unelected bureaucrat. These people have massive amounts of power. MASSIVE. They are unelected, so if they screw up, they are unaccountable to the people. If they cover the asses of their elected bosses, their bosses are happy, may issue them a public slap on the wrist, and they keep their jobs and their status.
The Prime Minister is trying to protect his historical record by downloading all the responsibility to the civil service, who are basically anonymous and out of the public reach. This is important. Keep this in mind.
Meanwhile, Gwen is off looking for Clement MacDonald who thinks she smells and tells her she’s pregnant.
Jack, having failed to acquire a child the hard way, decided to check out the children’s ward of the hospital. Rupesh gets a hold of him, and shoots Jack. Chick ninja assassin Johnson (sent from Frobisher) kills Rupesh. Turns out Rupesh was trying to infiltrate Torchwood as a spy, so this isn’t a big loss. Johnson implants Jack with a bomb, and when he wakes up, he’s sad to see Rupesh dead, and wanders back to the Hub.
In a miracle of science fiction vehicles to move the plot forward, Gwen’s at the Hub scanning her belly to see if she really is pregnant, everyone’s happy, Ianto’s lost the SUV, and ooops scanner shows there’s a bomb in Jack’s gut and everyone runs away. Well, Ianto wants to stay, but Jack pushes him onto the invisible lift, kisses him, tells him everything’s going to be fine, ( IT IS NOT GOING TO BE FINE) and the Hub goes KABOOM.
First, what about the weevils in the vaults? Poor poor Weevils. And the archives. The archives are now gone. Sniffle, I like archives.
Second, it was kind of ingenious of the government to blow Jack up retroactively, while he was in the Hub, thus intending to take out the team and the whole operation. Lucky that convenient piece of alien technology picks up bombs as well as babies, saving Gwen and Ianto so the show could go on. Considering Torchwood has saved the world a few times in the past few years, it seems a little bit of an overkill. What is the Torchwood exit strategy? Who would be around to clean up after the rift?
Third, why was the government trying to infiltrate Torchwood using Rupesh? I bet it was something inane like budgetary questions. Torchwood seems to get a lot of money to operate, what with being a secret agency over which the government has no jurisdiction. I bet he was really a doctor/financial analyst. I am mostly joking. More later on Torchwood sovereignty issues.
So I’ve decide that that was a whole lot, so I’m going to watch Day 2 tonight, and go through it tomorrow. Thoughts on Day One? We get to see a little more into Jack and Ianto’s life outside Torchwood, which extends their characters nicely. We also seem to be getting set up for socio-political commentary and we will keep our ears open for that. We are also forced to face that Jack and Ianto aren’t heroes in everyway. Ianto is insecure and forgets his family, getting eaten up by job he loves and a relationship that he will basically die for. Jack is loved by everyone, except his own daughter who seems to despise him and have a major grudge. He has no idea what’s going on with the children, has no way to find out, then he gets assasinated. All in all, it wasn’t a nice day for the Torchwood team. Cept Gwen… she’s preggers.